Category Archives: QCA

The COMPASSS statement and QCA solution types

About two weeks ago, COMPASSS issued a Statement on Rejecting Article Submissions because of QCA Solution Type. In short, the reasoning was that methodological work on QCA is developing and that reviewers and editors should not judge empirical work based … Continue reading

Posted in causal inference, causation, QCA, qualitative, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, regularity, set theory | Tagged , , , , , | 14 Comments

Don’t conflate fuzzy set membership with cases in QCA

How to properly interpret consistency and coverage values in fuzzy-set QCA. Continue reading

Posted in QCA, qualitative, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, set theory | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Curiosities of QCA: Fuzzy-set consistency

Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) is the method of choice for the analysis of set relations and has changed considerably and improved over the years. The more one delves into the method, however, the more things you (I, at least) stumble … Continue reading

Posted in QCA, qualitative, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, set relation, set theory | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

You are a regularity theorist when using the Coincidence Analysis algorithm in QCA

One of the recent big and, in my view, underappreciated innovations in the field of Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) is Baumgartner’s formulation of the Coincidence Analysis algorithm (CNA). Baumgartner presents it as an alternative to QCA, which I do not … Continue reading

Posted in algorithm, causal inference, causation, CNA, QCA, qualitative, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, Quine-McCluskey, regularity, set relation, set theory | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Another mistaken criticism of set theory and set-theoretic methods

For some time now, a discussion has been raging about the pros and cons of set theory and the use of set-theoretic methods (STM) in the social sciences (e.g., in Sociological Methodology and the APSA Newsletter). Following up on a … Continue reading

Posted in causal inference, causal mechanism, causation, comparative, process tracing, QCA, qualitative, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, set relation, set theory | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The irony of Lucas/Szatrowski’s QCA criticism

Among the recent criticisms of QCA, Lucas and Szatrowski’s (LS) critique stands out in multiple respects, including its scope, its tone (QCA is “a nonanalytic means to identify asymmetric causal illusions”, p. 66), and the responses it provoked (and the … Continue reading

Posted in QCA, Qualitative Comparative Analysis | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Reproducible QCA studies with fs/QCA

How to enhance reproducibility when using fs/QCA software Continue reading

Posted in QCA, Qualitative Comparative Analysis, replication, reproducability, set relation, set theory | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment